File talk:BeamKTDX.png

This and other images

This and other images are largely similar to their Kirby's Return to Dream Land counterparts. The uploader (Luigi1234) says that they are re-rendered version of it due to different shading. Personally, I can't see a difference between them, so I'm asking other people if they see it, and if there is, is it really big enough to keep them? Here is the complete list of files affected by it.

File:KRTDL Beam.png File:KRTDL Bomb.png File:KRTDL Crash.png File:KRTDL Cutter.png File:KRTDL Fighter.png File:KRTDL Fire.png File:KRTDL Ice.png File:KRTDL Leaf.png File:KRTDL Mike.png File:KRTDL Ninja.png File:KRTDL Parasol.png File:KRTDL Spear.png File:KRTDL Stone.png File:KRTDL Sword.png File:KRTDL Whip.png		File:BeamKTDX.png File:BombKTDX.png File:CrashKTDX.png File:CutterKTDX.png File:FighterKTDX.png File:FireKTDX.png File:IceKTDX.png File:LeafKTDX.png File:KTD Mike Kirby Artwork.png File:NinjaKTDX.png File:ParasolKTDX.png File:KTD Spear Kirby Artwork.png File:KTD Stone Kirby Artwork.png File:KTD Sword Kirby Artwork.png File:KTD Whip Kirby Artwork.png

Superbound (talk) 20:01, 12 November 2020 (UTC)

These images basically feature bigger eyes for Kirby and different, "lighter" shading, since those changed in his incarnation in Triple Deluxe and moving forward. If you compare the faces in particular, I'm sure you can notice that.

I'm not sure what policy we have for those; render updates like that are pretty common not just for Kirby, but for multiple game series (Mario does that a lot as an example). Personally myself I don't see I need to keep those around, but at the same time I suppose it doesn't hurt. Ultimately, however, with such minor differences, I think the original images work well enough, and we don't need the updated renders. - Gigi (talk • edits) 20:18, 12 November 2020 (UTC)

In my opinion, these different images, no matter how many minor differences there are, should count as a separate image. That's how it works on the Super Mario Wiki. – Owencrazyboy17 (talk) 05:39, 13 November 2020 (UTC)

I agree with Owen. In my opinion, we should definitely keep them, no matter how small the differences are. I also think using the originals will work just fine. -- Jellytost♡ (talk) 06:30, 13 November 2020 (UTC)

I see, I guess there is the difference then, however, I don't think it's big enough to keep them. I wonder how they look in gallery-size size on computer and on phone.

• 

  KRDL

• 

  KTD

• 

  KRDL

• 

  KTD

• 

  KRDL

• 

  KTD

• 

  KRTDL

• 

  KTD

(Switching to phone in a moment) Superbound (talk) 18:04, 16 November 2020 (UTC)