Talk:100% completion

Deluxe versions of Sub-Games

Every "Deluxe" expansion of a 3DS Sub-Game has 100% requirements listed, but these games all lack a formal percentage counter (to my knowledge) or even a mention of 100% completion. It doesn't make much sense to me that they're on this page with completion requirements stated as if they're concrete and official. The Kirby Fighters Deluxe requirement seems especially arbitrary, as unlocking every Rare Outfit is given little acknowledgment by the game; certainly not as much as one might expect for a 100%. Should the sections be rewritten, possibly removed entirely, or left as is? Rubybirdy (talk) 19:05, 23 April 2024 (UTC)

Yeah, I do think we should make a clearer distinction between games that have actual completion percentage trackers and games where it isn't tracked and the "100% completion" is unofficial. I'm not sure if I want to remove them, but maybe have them split into a separate section? StarPunch (talk) 19:12, 23 April 2024 (UTC)

We shouldn't remove these games, as all have commemorative messages for some sort of informal 100% achievement (like clearing Very Hard with all abilities for KFD). But we can reword them like the Kirby's Star Stacker sections to explain there is no formal percentage gauge but you can unlock the commemorative messages, and some things can be considered informal completion. - Gigi (talk • edits) 19:13, 23 April 2024 (UTC)

Rename 100% completion to "Completion"

Could we rename 100% completion to use the title "Completion" instead, especially for technical reasons? I've attempted to type in "100% completion" when searching from the address bar and it gave me an error 400 Bad Request. Same occurs with accessing the article from the WiKirby RC log on the Shiver Star Discord. I typed in Completion and it redirects me to the article properly. I also feel Completion is a better title since the Super Mario Wiki also uses this title to refer to 100% completion. --  (profile ::: talk) 01:21, 24 April 2024 (UTC)

Due to redirects existing, I don't think we need to move the page for technical reasons, in particular when we have other pages like ??? and Guest Star ???? Star Allies Go! that has the same problem as the name of this page and I don't think we should rename them either. And due to how most games call it 100% completion in some way, I prefer to keep it as 100% completion. I also feel "completion" and "100% completion" imply different things; for example, it's one thing to complete a game, but another to 100% complete a game. In short, I'm against the rename. - Gigi (talk • edits) 01:26, 24 April 2024 (UTC)

I concur with that Gigi has said. It's all well and good for the Super Mario Wiki to do things one way, but in the Kirby series, the term "100%" is used frequently, so it makes sense to prioritize that here. As Gigi has pointed out, redirects exist if you have a problem getting to the page, and more can be made if needed. --Samwell (talk) 03:21, 24 April 2024 (UTC)